The Thoughtful Christian Logo
Resources for Christians and seekers
Carlier; Jennifer Carlier; addiction; recovery; drugs; drug abuse; abuse; alcohol; alcoholics anonymous; al anon; 12 steps; basement; church; theology; addiction studies; study; research; scholarship; john calvin; calvinism; luther; augustine; wilderness; S26
Finding God in the Basement

Reimagining a Theology of Addiction and Recovery

Availability:
7-10 days processing
Publisher:
Westminster John Knox Press
Publication Date:
1/13/2026
ISBN:
9780664268589
Pages:
210
Trim Size
6 x 9
Product Type:
Paper

Finding God in the Basement reimagines the Christian theology of sin and salvation through the lens of addiction, offering a liberative vision of human dignity, hope for recovery, and communal transformation.

In Finding God in the Basement, Jennifer Carlier offers a theologically incisive critique of how Christian doctrines of sin and salvation fail to engage the lived realities of addiction and recovery. Drawing from her own experiences and from memoirs that recount others’ journeys through addiction and recovery, Carlier blends storytelling with theological scholarship and insights from addiction studies to offer a liberative theological framework for talking about addiction in a way that reimagines it, accounting for not only the profound suffering of addiction but also the hope of recovery.

Carlier offers a sharp critique of theological models of sin and salvation that reinforce shame and render the church an inhospitable or even harmful place for those suffering from addiction. In their place, she constructs a theological vision that affirms both human dignity in brokenness and a grounded hope for recovery and wholeness. She draws on the Augustinian concept of the bondage of the will, reimagined in conversation with contemporary understandings of addiction, to name the realities of addiction and human brokenness, and she lifts up the biblical exodus narrative as a more generative metaphor for salvation that accounts for both the challenge and hope for liberation and recovery in the present moment. This theological reframing is not only about individual healing for those with addiction but also about reshaping communal practices.

Carlier invites churches to learn from the recovery communities that often gather in their basements, where authenticity, mutual accountability, acceptance, and daily practices of living into freedom are valued. In doing so, Finding God in the Basement contributes meaningfully to ongoing conversations in constructive theology, practical theology, and Christian ethics, offering a compelling vision of what Christian communities might become when they center grace, authenticity, and vulnerability.

Product Excerpts and Related Resources:
Download excerpt from Finding God in the Basement

Jennifer Carlier is the Associate Dean for Academic Programs at Columbia Theological Seminary in Decatur, Georgia. Her research and teaching focus on the encounter between lived experience and theology and seek to reimagine theologies and practices that are liberative for underrepresented communities. Her research interests include queer and feminist theologies, the intersections of theology and mental health, metaphorical theology, and moral injury. The recipient of multiple fellowships, including a Louisville Institute Post-Doctoral Fellowship and a Stembler Fellowship from First Presbyterian Church of Atlanta, Carlier's talk "Finding God in the Basement" won the first TheoEd Graduate Prize in Public Theology in 2022. In her spare time, Carlier is an avid fan of Legos, strategy board games, pickleball, and woodworking.


1
Finding God in the...
Reimagining a Theo...
by Westminster John Knox Press
 

"Dr. Carlier's new book is a wonderful addition to pastoral care and systematic theology. She provides a much needed corrective to models of addiction that focus on blame by appealing to the lived experiences of addicts. She offers a fierce indictment of the way some atonement theories have exacerbated the suffering of addicts and proposes a refreshing antidote. As is often the case, the news from the "basement" makes available life-giving insight to the human condition and to theology's role in addressing human suffering."

—Wendy Farley, Rice Family Chair of Spirituality, San Francisco Theological Seminary

 

"At once theologically acute and pastorally wise, Jennifer Carlier's Finding God in the Basement merits a place at the center of conversations about how church communities can better respond to persons with addictions. The chapters on the impact of atonement theories on persons' ability to recover from addiction alone are worth the read. Carlier, however, follows up these chapters with deeply informed recommendations for how church communities can alter their own practices in order to become more hospitable to all, including their own members. 48.5 million people in the United States have addictions; churches cannot be churches without following the many insights that Carlier offers."

—Todd Whitmore, Associate Professor of Theology and Anthropology, University of Notre Dame

 

"There is no shortage of books on addiction, or even on addiction and the church, but none of them provides the kind of sustained reflection on Christian faith and practice found in Finding God in the Basement.  Carlier's argument, at once existentially gripping and theologically astute, offers a vision of salvation for those living with addiction that is as realistic in its analysis as it is uncompromising in its hope."

—Ian A. McFarland, Robert W. Woodruff Professor of Theology, Emory University; <

"Filled with beautiful writing, insightful critique, and concrete suggestions, Finding God in the Basement represents the very best of constructive theology oriented toward liberation and healing. Dr. Carlier offers crucial theological analysis of beliefs and practices that exacerbate shame and undermine recovery. In their stead, she highlights models and metaphors that sustain practices of healing. Finding God in the Basement is a gift to all who struggle with addiction and to the loved ones and church communities journeying with them."

—Ellen Ott Marshall, Professor of Christian Ethics and Conflict Transformation, Candler School of Theology

 

"Theological treatments of addiction are limited, especially ones which single out a particular doctrine as a culprit.  But Jennifer Carlier does just this, asserting that the ‘penal substitutionary’ view of the atonement (that God needs recompense for our sin in order to forgive us) is the very thing which keeps people with addiction mired in shame and guilt. She suggests that only the 'bondage of the will' aspect of original sin makes sense for sufferers. Replete with her own and others' personal stories, this book makes a good case for a more liberative theology."

—Rev. Dr. Linda Mercadante, Ph.D., Distinguished Research Professor Emerita, Methodist Theological School in Ohio, founder of HealthyBeliefs.org

 

"There are two kinds of people in the United States: those who feel the crushing crisis of addiction and those who will soon. Jennifer Carlier provides a much-needed resource for Christians of all kinds, offering a medical and scientific understanding of addiction, a theological grounding for the challenge, and a framework of hope for recovery. This book will undoubtedly find its way out of the basement and into seminaries, as well as into the hands of church leaders across the country. The story told is about more than addiction and recovery, but about the journey everyone must make from a place of bondage to a new life of freedom."

—Timothy McMahan King, author of Addiction Nation: What The Opioid Crisis Reveals About Us

comments powered by Disqus
List Price: $35.00
Sale Price:
$22.75 - 35% off